Arthur Hoyt
Budington

Barnett Parker
Longfellow's Butler

Charles Lane
Hallor, The Semple's Lawyer.

Douglass Dumbrille
John Cedar

Emma Dunn
Mrs. Meredith, housekeeper

Gary Cooper
Longfellow Deeds/Cinderella Man

George 'Gabby' Hayes
Farmer's Spokesman

George Bancroft
MacWade aka Mac

Gustav von Seyffertitz
Dr. EmileVon Hallor

H.B. Warner
Judge May

Jameson Thomas
Mr. Semple

Jean Arthur
Louise 'Babe' Bennett/Mary Dawson

John Wray
Farmer

Lionel Stander
Cornelius Cobb

Margaret McWade
Amy Faulkner

Margaret Seddon
Jane Faulkner

Margarete Matzenauer
Madame Pomponi

Mayo Methot
Mrs. Semple

Pierre Watkin
Arthur Cedar

Raymond Walburn
Walter

Ruth Donnelly
Mabel Dawson

Spencer Charters
Mal, station agent

Stanley Andrews
James Cedar

Walter Catlett
Morrow